Second Opinions
MRI Reviews
Insurance Accepted
Open Late Nights
On-Site X-Ray Machine & Ultrasound
For Diagnostics & Emergency Injuries
Hammertoe Treatment in Keansburg, NJ | NJ Sports Spine & Wellness
The toe didn't always look like that. Maybe it started after a long stretch in shoes that pinched, or after a bunion changed how your foot loaded weight, or after your second toe just quietly decided one day not to lie flat anymore. Then a corn appeared on top of the joint, where shoes rub. Then a callus showed up under the ball of the foot. And now the toe stays bent - even when nothing is pressing against it.
Hammertoes are common, progressive, and very treatable. Our podiatrist at NJ Sports Spine & Wellness in Keansburg, NJ sees them at every stage - from a barely noticeable curl that responds to a different shoe, to a rigid, painful deformity that needs surgical correction. The right approach depends on how flexible the toe still is, how much it hurts, and what you need your feet to do.
This page covers what a hammertoe is, why they develop, how we treat them, and what makes our practice a good fit for serious foot care.
- Hammertoe Treatment in Keansburg, NJ
- What Is a Hammertoe?
- Common Hammertoe Symptoms
- What Causes a Hammertoe?
- Non-Surgical Hammertoe Treatment in Keansburg, NJ
- Hammertoe Surgery in Keansburg, NJ
- Benefits of Minimally Invasive Hammertoe Correction in Keansburg, NJ
- Why Choose NJ Sports Spine & Wellness for Hammertoe Treatment in Keansburg, NJ
- Frequently Asked Questions About Hammertoes
What Is a Hammertoe?
A hammertoe is a toe deformity in which the middle joint of the toe bends downward, forcing the tip to point toward the floor. The shape resembles the head of a hammer - which is exactly where the name comes from. It most commonly affects the second, third, or fourth toe, and it often shows up in feet that already have a bunion or significant mechanical issues.
Hammertoes fall into two categories, and the distinction matters for treatment:
Flexible hammertoe
The toe is bent but can still be manually straightened. Treatment focuses on preserving flexibility, controlling pain, and slowing progression.
Rigid hammertoe
The toe has lost the ability to straighten. The joint has stiffened, and surgical correction is usually the most effective path forward.
Most hammertoes start flexible and gradually become rigid if they aren't addressed. That's why earlier care almost always means more options.
Common Hammertoe Symptoms
Hammertoes announce themselves through both visual changes and patterns of pain. Many patients first notice the appearance - a toe that's curled where it didn't used to be, or that stays bent even when there's no shoe touching it. The discomfort tends to follow shortly after.
Common signs of a hammertoe include:
- A visibly bent middle toe joint
- A corn or thickened skin on top of the affected toe, from shoe friction
- Calluses on the ball of the foot beneath the bent toe
- Pain in the toe when walking, standing, or wearing certain shoes
- Redness, swelling, or warmth around the joint
- Stiffness or reduced range of motion in the toe
- Open sores or blisters in advanced cases, especially in patients with diabetes
- Difficulty finding shoes that don't aggravate the joint
The corn or callus is often what brings patients in. The pain at the top of the toe - where shoes rub against the raised joint - becomes a daily irritation that doesn't respond to home remedies, because the underlying problem is structural.
What Causes a Hammertoe?
A hammertoe develops when the muscles and tendons that control the toe fall out of balance. The tendons that pull the toe up and the ones that pull it down work against each other, and when that balance shifts - usually over years - the joint settles into a bent position.
Several factors contribute to that imbalance:
- Genetics and foot structure - Some feet are simply built in a way that predisposes them to hammertoes. If your parents had them, your risk is higher.
- Footwear - Shoes that crowd the toes - narrow, pointed, or too short - force them into a bent position over and over until the position becomes permanent. High heels concentrate the problem by pushing weight forward.
- Bunions - When a bunion pushes the big toe inward, it crowds the neighboring toes and often triggers hammertoe formation in the second toe.
- Arthritis - Inflammatory joint disease damages the small joints of the toes and can lead to progressive deformity.
- Injury - A previous toe fracture, jam, or trauma can alter mechanics and trigger a hammertoe over time.
- Nerve and muscle conditions - Diabetes, peripheral neuropathy, and certain neurological conditions weaken the small muscles of the foot and can accelerate hammertoe formation.
The takeaway: you didn't get a bunion because you wore the wrong shoes once. It's almost always a combination of how your foot is built and how it's been used over years.
Non-Surgical Hammertoe Treatment in Keansburg, NJ
When a hammertoe is still flexible, conservative care can be remarkably effective. The goal isn't full anatomical correction - once the joint has started bending, complete straightening usually requires surgery - but to control pain, preserve flexibility, and slow the slide toward a rigid joint.
Our podiatrist builds non-surgical plans around what's actually causing your symptoms. Common options include:
Footwear changes
This is often the single most important step. Shoes with a wider, deeper toe box give the toes room to lie flat. Soft, flexible uppers reduce friction over the bent joint. Lower heels shift weight off the forefoot. These changes alone can dramatically reduce pain.
Custom orthotics
A properly designed orthotic supports the arch, controls pronation, and redistributes pressure away from the ball of the foot and the bent toe joint. For patients whose hammertoes are driven by foot mechanics - not just shoes - orthotics are often the most impactful single treatment.
Toe splints and pads
Gel pads cushion the corn or callus and reduce friction inside the shoe. Splints can hold the toe in a straighter position and help maintain flexibility. Neither corrects the underlying deformity, but both can meaningfully reduce day-to-day pain.
Stretching and strengthening exercises
Targeted exercises - toe stretches, towel scrunches, marble pickups - strengthen the small intrinsic muscles of the foot and improve toe flexibility. When a hammertoe is caught early, consistent exercise can slow or sometimes halt progression.
Anti-inflammatory care
For flare-ups, ice protocols, topical or oral anti-inflammatories, and occasional corticosteroid injections can break the pain cycle and let the joint calm down.
Physical therapy
Because NJ Sports Spine & Wellness brings podiatry and physical therapy under one roof, our podiatrist often coordinates with our PT team for gait retraining and lower-extremity strengthening when foot mechanics are part of the picture.
Many patients with flexible hammertoes manage them effectively for years on this kind of layered plan. The conversation about surgery starts when the joint stiffens, when conservative care can no longer control the pain, or when secondary problems - like recurring infected corns or skin ulcers - start showing up.
Hammertoe Surgery in Keansburg, NJ
When a hammertoe has become rigid, or when pain persists despite consistent conservative care, surgical correction can realign the toe and resolve the symptoms that have been pulling your attention down to your foot all day.
Several surgical approaches are available, and the right one depends on the specifics of your deformity:
Tendon release or transfer
for flexible hammertoes that don't respond to conservative care. The procedure rebalances the tendons that are pulling the toe into the bent position.
Arthroplasty
for rigid hammertoes. A small portion of the stiffened joint is removed to allow the toe to straighten.
Arthrodesis (joint fusion)
for severe, painful rigid hammertoes. The joint is fused in a corrected position, providing permanent stability and pain relief.
Many of these corrections can now be performed using minimally invasive techniques. Small incisions, specialized instruments, and modern fixation hardware allow the procedure to be done with less trauma to the surrounding tissue. The cosmetic result is better, and patients generally experience less postoperative discomfort and a sooner return to walking.
Our podiatrist will examine your foot, review imaging, and recommend the approach most likely to give you a durable, functional result - not just for the affected toe, but for your foot as a whole.
Benefits of Minimally Invasive Hammertoe Correction in Keansburg, NJ
Modern minimally invasive techniques have changed what hammertoe surgery looks like and feels like:
- Smaller incisions and minimal visible scarring
- Less disruption to surrounding tendons and soft tissue
- Reduced post-operative swelling and discomfort
- Earlier weight-bearing in most cases
- Precise correction of the joint with modern fixation
- Better long-term cosmetic and functional outcomes
These advantages matter especially for patients who want their feet to look and function normally, and who can't afford to be off their feet for an extended period.
Why Choose NJ Sports Spine & Wellness for Hammertoe Treatment in Keansburg, NJ
A hammertoe rarely exists in isolation. It usually shows up alongside a bunion, alongside arch problems, or in the context of a foot whose mechanics have been off for years. Treating the toe without considering everything around it tends to produce short-term relief and long-term frustration.
That's where our integrated approach matters:
A board-certified podiatrist with both conservative and surgical expertise
You won't be funneled toward surgery because that's the only tool available. Our podiatrist treats the full spectrum of hammertoe presentations - from early, flexible deformities to rigid, painful joints - and recommends what's genuinely best for your foot.
A multidisciplinary team under one roof
Hammertoes often connect to broader mechanical issues. Our Keansburg, NJ office combines podiatry with physical therapy, chiropractic care, sports medicine, and pain management - so you can address the toe and the upstream causes in one place.
Sports medicine experience
Many of our patients are athletes, runners, or active adults who need their feet to perform, not just survive. Our care model is built around getting people back to the activities they love.
Patient education that respects your time
You'll leave your first appointment knowing what you have, what your options are, and what we'd recommend and why. No pressure, no upsell - just the information you need to make a good decision.
Local, accessible care
Our Keansburg, NJ office is built around making thorough foot care convenient, with appointment availability designed to fit real schedules.
Frequently Asked Questions About Hammertoes
A flexible hammertoe - one that can still be manually moved into a straight position - can often be managed effectively with non-surgical care. Splints, taping, exercises, orthotics, and the right shoes can reduce pain and slow progression. A rigid hammertoe, where the joint has stiffened, cannot be fully straightened without surgical correction. That's why early evaluation matters: the sooner we see the toe, the more likely conservative care will be enough.
All three involve abnormal bending of the smaller toes, but the affected joints differ. A hammertoe bends at the middle joint of the toe. A mallet toe bends at the joint closest to the toenail. A claw toe involves bending at both joints, often combined with an upward bend at the base of the toe. Treatment principles overlap considerably, though the specific surgical approach may vary.
Look for shoes with a wide, deep toe box that doesn't press down on the bent joint. Soft, flexible uppers reduce friction over the corn or callus. A low heel shifts weight away from the forefoot. Stiff-soled shoes can also help by reducing the bending forces on the toes. Many athletic and comfort-focused brands now make styles specifically designed for patients with toe deformities.
Look for a wide, rounded toe box that doesn't squeeze the joint, a low heel (under one inch is ideal), soft and flexible upper material that won't rub the bunion, and good arch support. Many athletic and walking brands now make models specifically designed with bunion-friendly features. During your appointment, our podiatrist can recommend specific styles that suit the shape of your foot.
Recurrence is uncommon when the underlying foot mechanics are addressed alongside the surgical correction. If a hammertoe is corrected but the original drivers - poor footwear, untreated bunions, abnormal pronation - aren't addressed, the deformity can return over time. A comprehensive treatment plan that combines surgery with mechanical correction and supportive care offers the best long-term results.
Take the Next Step Toward Pain-Free Feet
If you've been managing around a bent toe - adjusting your shoes, dodging the corn, hoping it doesn't get worse - there's a better path forward. Our podiatry team in Keansburg, NJ can examine your foot, identify exactly what's happening, and build a plan that fits your life.
Schedule a consultation today. Call (908) 866-7246 or request an appointment online - we offer same-day availability for many appointments.
Latest News in Keansburg, NJ
Keansburg Fishing Pier collapses into frozen Raritan Bay
Eyewitness Newshttps://abc7ny.com/post/keansburg-fishing-pier-collapses-ocean-monmouth-county-nj-no-injuries/18538093/
KEANSBURG, New Jersey (WABC) -- Ice is being blamed for causing part of the Keansburg Fishing Pier to collapse in New Jersey.A drone video captured the aftermath, showing part of the pier had fallen into the Raritan Bay.There were no reports of any injuries.Keansburg Fishing Pier is located at the back of the Keansburg Amusement Park in the Raritan Bay.The private, family-owned recreation destination has been in operation since 1904.----------Submit a tip or story idea to Eyewitness NewsHave...
KEANSBURG, New Jersey (WABC) -- Ice is being blamed for causing part of the Keansburg Fishing Pier to collapse in New Jersey.
A drone video captured the aftermath, showing part of the pier had fallen into the Raritan Bay.
There were no reports of any injuries.
Keansburg Fishing Pier is located at the back of the Keansburg Amusement Park in the Raritan Bay.
The private, family-owned recreation destination has been in operation since 1904.
----------
Submit a tip or story idea to Eyewitness News
Have a breaking news tip or an idea for a story we should cover? Send it to Eyewitness News using the form below. If attaching a video or photo, terms of use apply.
If submitting a photo or video, you confirm that you took the attached image/video and are its copyright owner; or that you are the copyright owner’s authorized agent; or that you own, purchased or otherwise legally obtained the rights to the image/video. In addition, you confirm that you have all of the necessary rights and permissions to grant us this license for its use.
You give WABC-TV non-exclusive permission to reproduce, use and edit the image/video on all platforms, in all media (now known or hereafter developed), including, without limitation, broadcast, online, streaming and social media, for any purpose, including, but not limited to, promotional uses, worldwide in perpetuity.
You give WABC-TV permission to distribute the image/video to its licensees, including, but not limited to, owned stations, affiliates, partners, licensees and assigns, for their use on all platforms, in all media (now known or hereafter developed), including, without limitation, broadcast, online, streaming and social media, for any purpose, including, but not limited to, promotional uses, worldwide in perpetuity.
You understand that you will receive no payment or royalty for any use under this agreement; that WABC-TV is under no obligation to use, edit or distribute the material; and that you have no right to inspect or approve any use of the material.
For full terms, click here.
It's Not Just Keansburg Fishing Pier: Frozen Raritan Bay Is Uprooting Pilings In Many Marinas
Carly Baldwinhttps://patch.com/new-jersey/middletown-nj/its-not-just-keansburg-fishing-pier-frozen-raritan-bay-uprooting-pilings
KEANSBURG, NJ — It's not just the Keansburg fishing pier: Marinas all along Raritan Bay are witnessing their wooden pilings uprooted by ice."The ice is freezing around the pilings," said Gary Carr, who owns multiple fishing shops along Raritan Bay, including Fishing Flea Market Bait & Tackle in Keyport and Keyport Bait & Tackle. "As the high tide comes in — and we just had a full moon two days ago — the water level rises four to five feet. It's literally pulling the pilings out of the ground. T...
KEANSBURG, NJ — It's not just the Keansburg fishing pier: Marinas all along Raritan Bay are witnessing their wooden pilings uprooted by ice.
"The ice is freezing around the pilings," said Gary Carr, who owns multiple fishing shops along Raritan Bay, including Fishing Flea Market Bait & Tackle in Keyport and Keyport Bait & Tackle. "As the high tide comes in — and we just had a full moon two days ago — the water level rises four to five feet. It's literally pulling the pilings out of the ground. The next high tide keeps pulling them more and more out of the ground. So if it doesn't thaw out, the pilings just keep getting pulled out."
That's exactly what happened to the Keansburg Fishing Pier, a beloved local fishing spot that extends about 2,000 feet into Raritan Bay. At midday Tuesday, the portion of the wooden pier that's farthest into the bay collapsed; see video of the damaged pier here. Carr shared this photo of the damage: https://www.facebook.com/photo...
"It's not just the Keansburg pier," he said. "There are marinas up and down the coast that are worried this is going to happen to them next."
"I would say every marina in this area is going to have repercussions because of this ice," said John DeSilvestri, the owner of Keyport Marine Basin. He too has had some pilings uprooted by ice, he said Wednesday.
"I just called a company to come out and look at it," he said. "The last time I saw the bay this frozen was in the '70s, '80s. It's just Mother Nature. We won't know how bad the damage is until it all thaws."
The ice on Raritan Bay is so thick this winter that Seastreak canceled its ferry service out of Highlands and Atlantic Highlands. It is still running limited ferry service from Belford, where they are using a tugboat as an icebreaker. Competitor NY Waterway had to cancel some ferry routes from South Amboy and is substituting with buses. NY Waterway also has an ice-breaking boat.
And with temperatures expected to plummet back down to the single digits this weekend, don't expect Raritan Bay to unfreeze anytime soon.
"Highlands Marina is worried," said Carr. "People are asking what's gonna happen to the Navy Pier (in Middletown); we think that will be OK. But it may get worse in the next full moon phase coming up in two weeks. We're not gonna be out of this for a month."
"I'm 50 years old and I've never seen (the bay) frozen like this," said Carr. "I've seen it skim over in past winters, but nothing like this. The last time I saw the bay frozen like this was photos from the 1920s."
The Keansburg fishing pier is owned by the Gehlhaus family, the same family that owns Keansburg Amusement Park. A woman named Kathi Smock manages the pier, a job she took over from her father. She told News 12 Tuesday she plans to rebuild.
"I hope they do," said Carr. "It's a great local staple."
Seastreak ferry commuter John Tachine provided this video of frozen Raritan Bay on Jan. 30, 2026:
Disclaimer:
Service Areas
